Prime Minister Modi’s recent endorsement of a Secular Civil Code (SCC) has reignited conversations about modernizing India’s legal system. His call for an SCC, referenced in his Independence Day speech, reflects a new approach compared to the long-discussed Uniform Civil Code (UCC). Both the SCC and UCC aim for unified laws, but they approach India’s cultural diversity differently. Here’s a look at these two concepts and their potential impact on India’s future.
The Uniform Civil Code (UCC): One Law for All
The Uniform Civil Code (UCC) proposes a single set of laws for all citizens, regardless of religion. It would regulate personal matters like marriage, divorce, inheritance, and adoption. Article 44 of the Constitution encourages the state to work toward a UCC as a means of promoting unity and equality. However, this directive is non-binding and remains a goal rather than a requirement.
Today, different personal laws apply to various communities in India—Hindu law, Muslim law, Christian law, and others—each granting different rights. Goa is an exception; under the Portuguese Civil Code of 1867, all its citizens are governed by the same set of laws, a model the Supreme Court has praised. Yet, the UCC remains an unresolved issue across India.
What is the Secular Civil Code (SCC)?
The Secular Civil Code (SCC) aims to offer a middle ground, emphasizing equality without requiring full uniformity across all personal laws. The SCC would uphold secular principles but still allow certain religious customs, as long as they don’t infringe on fundamental rights like equality and justice.
This approach aligns with Dr. B.R. Ambedkar’s vision of a secular India where all citizens are treated equally, but without disregarding the country’s cultural diversity. Under the SCC, religious customs would coexist with secular rights, balancing cultural respect with legal equality.
Background of the UCC and SCC
The idea of a Uniform Civil Code traces back to colonial India, where the British unified laws on crimes and contracts but left religious personal laws untouched. After Independence, the Hindu Code Bill of 1956 reformed Hindu law, strengthening women’s rights. Dr. Ambedkar initially supported a UCC but acknowledged the challenges of imposing a single code in India’s diverse society.
Ambedkar’s vision suggested a secular approach that respects religious freedoms and individual rights, a vision more closely aligned with the SCC today. While the UCC aims for one standard law, the SCC respects diversity by allowing religious customs within a secular framework.
Constitutional Provisions and Practical Challenges
- Article 44 of the Indian Constitution promotes a UCC for social equality, but Articles 25 and 26 protect religious freedom, making the idea of a single code complex.
- The Sixth Schedule of the Constitution also allows some regions to retain their own laws, further highlighting the challenges of enforcing a UCC.
A UCC might unify personal laws across India, but it could also infringe on religious practices, particularly for minority communities. The Law Commission of India in 2018 recommended reforms within each religion’s laws as a gradual path toward uniformity, rather than implementing an immediate UCC.
Comparing UCC and SCC: Key Benefits
Both the UCC and SCC seek to create a more integrated society but with different methods:
- Legal Consistency
- UCC: Would streamline personal laws, reducing legal inconsistencies.
- SCC: Offers consistent standards while respecting cultural diversity, achieving efficient but inclusive governance.
- Gender Equality
- UCC: A uniform law could guarantee equal rights for women across all communities.
- SCC: Doesn’t impose uniformity but ensures gender justice by requiring that religious customs align with basic rights like property and maintenance.
- Religious Freedom
- UCC: Promotes equality but may impact religious expression.
- SCC: Balances religious practices with equality, preserving cultural identity.
- National Unity
- UCC: Reinforces unity by applying the same law to all citizens.
- SCC: Promotes unity through diversity, fostering harmony without requiring uniformity.
Why the SCC Might Be a Better Fit for India
The SCC has several potential advantages over the UCC in India’s diverse society:
- Balanced Reforms: The SCC encourages gradual, widely accepted reforms without enforcing full uniformity.
- Gender Justice: It addresses gender disparities while allowing cultural practices, offering a fairer path to equal rights.
- Social Harmony: Less likely to face resistance, the SCC respects cultural practices while promoting equality.
- Adaptable: Allows gradual integration of secular principles, making it less disruptive.
Moving Forward: A Vision for Inclusive Progress
The idea of a Secular Civil Code offers a path toward a more inclusive India. Modi’s vision for the SCC resonates with Ambedkar’s dream of a unified yet diverse nation, where individual freedoms are balanced with shared rights. Implementing the SCC would require open dialogue, engaging all communities in shaping a fair and cohesive society that respects India’s unique heritage.
You can also read the latest judgement by visiting [Latest Judgment].
For more information, visit [ALEC Enquiry].
